LOADING

What is the thesis (the central idea or main point)?

Richard Dawkins’ main argument is that the forces of evolution give an illusion of deliberate design, whereas in truth, they were shaped by gradual and random mutations sifted by the filters of natural selection.

What are the main arguments made in supporting the thesis?

Drawing on the analogy of the watchmaker by William Paley, Dawkins produces his polemic by systematically dismantling the theory by design as applicable to life forms on earth. Dawkins shows that random mutations at the level of the DNA, when filtered and selected under the process of natural selection, gives rise to sophisticated and specialized species. His main argument is that there is no need whatsoever for invoking divine intervention in explaining variety and magnificence of life on earth.

What are the important implications of the author’s position?

The most important implication of Dawkins’ position is that it undermines the theological view that humans as superior to other species. Under the powers of natural selection humans are just one twig at the end of a grand tree of life (both extinct and still existent). Hence, The Blind Watchmaker weakens the homo-centric view of the world.

Is what is said clear? How is it unclear?

Dawkins’s arguments are very clear and logical. The analogies and turns of phrase evident in the text are of high literary quality as well.

Are the arguments adequate to support the claims? Are the premises true? The assumptions dubious?

Since Dawkins is exclusively dealing with supporting a scientific theory with empirical and verifiable fact, there is very little inadequacy in the scholarship. As for assumptions and premises, there are hardly any that he makes.

Are the arguments adequate to support the claims? Are the premises true? The assumptions dubious?

Dawkins uses computer generated models of mutations and gene selection across generations. This way, he gives a virtual demonstration of how evolution occurs in the natural world. It is as if we are witnessing evolution at work. Dawkins also uses principles from game theory and economics to support his claims. Open minded people will find hardly anything disputable in the Blind Watchmaker.

Do the implications of the text lead to absurd or false consequences?

Reading the text leads to an enlightenment view of life on earth. It does not lead to absurd or false conclusions.

Are important aspects of the issue overlooked?

Being a thorough-going polemic that he is, Dawkins leaves no false premise unexposed. So, it is fair to say that all aspects of the issue are given attention.

How well did the author accomplish his or her goal?

Richard Dawkins scholarship succeeds in what it set out to do. It beautifully illustrates an important scientific theory in jargon-free language. The text inspires the reader to explore the subject further. It also serves as a wake-up call to religious people and prompts them to revisit their ingrained assumptions about life on earth and the position of humans in it.

What is the thesis (the central idea or main point)?

Richard Dawkins’ main argument is that the forces of evolution give an illusion of deliberate design, whereas in truth, they were shaped by gradual and random mutations sifted by the filters of natural selection.

What are the main arguments made in supporting the thesis?

Drawing on the analogy of the watchmaker by William Paley, Dawkins produces his polemic by systematically dismantling the theory by design as applicable to life forms on earth. Dawkins shows that random mutations at the level of the DNA, when filtered and selected under the process of natural selection, gives rise to sophisticated and specialized species. His main argument is that there is no need whatsoever for invoking divine intervention in explaining variety and magnificence of life on earth.

What are the important implications of the author’s position?

The most .

close

HAVEN’T FOUND ESSAY YOU WANT?

Get your custom essay sample

FOR ONLY $13.90/PAGE

Nora
Tucker

Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out